BOOM! A Late Appreciation For John Madden

A Sports Scribe, Football — By on August 16, 2012 at 11:06 am

As a nation preps its veins for its greatest addiction – football is America’s heroin, if you don’t know – there’s something that even three years later seems a bit … off. No, it’s not just replacement officials, the apparent end of the diva wide receiver era or the painful void of a good touchdown celebration.

As crazy as this might sound, I miss John Madden.

It hasn’t been that long since the legendary coach and analyst parked his ginormous motor coach for good, but as those seasons go by, you’d be hard-pressed to find someone who appreciated his style as much as this Scribe.

It was a style that over time grew a bit stale for some. While it was never off-putting, some were certainly turned off by the fawning of the game’s most reckless gunslinger. And ultimately, it was one that lacked in all of the extremism that exists in the national NFL booths today.

Yet, it worked for three decades.

When in the booth, Madden did something that seemingly NO ONE attempts to do anymore. He kept things simple enough that the casual fan didn’t exactly feel overwhelmed with football terminology. At the same time, he provided enough that a die-hard fan could test his or her knowledge of the game. It was a hard balance that even in our era of highly advanced camera technology and bite-sized morsels of play reviews can’t seem to replicate.

Despite the much-mocked appreciation for Brett Favre – who is no longer just a kid out there – Madden was phenomenally objective. If you can name a time where Madden ever lambasted a team or even a troubled player during a broadcast, it was certainly rarer than a Tim Couch highlight reel. When sports media types of his time talked about offensive linemen and fullbacks as unsung heroes in contrast of their more popular teammates, he was one of the few to single out the motions of those men on a consistent basis. After all, he had an affinity for guys that did the dirty work to make the game what it is today.

You can argue that a major reason that appreciation for Madden has gone by the wayside over the years is … well, Madden. The video game franchise he created became a definitive staple of the Millennials/Generation Y. Not only could we simulate the game we just watched the physical Madden telestrate on Sunday, but we could actually simulate entire seasons and franchises. With a brilliant group of engineers and designers behind him, the Madden franchise acted as a proving ground on how we fans would run a team despite how phenomenally terrible we would be at it in real life.

Suddenly, video game tendencies shaped our psyches. Never run the ball or pass to the intermediate receiver, don’t stop blitzing and go for it on fourth down at all times. We figured that we have our master’s degrees in Madden Football, and we know everything there is to know about the game, so there was no need for Madden in the booth anymore.

Yet, his approach to calling the game is exactly what’s needed today.

We demand television analysts to “tell it like it is,” even though at some point, they’ll predictably tick us off by saying something asinine, inaccurate and/or amazingly biased. For that reason, we have much more snark and condescension in the booth than before, just as NBC and ESPN have given us with their Sunday and Monday night games. We also have jargon that will completely go over the heads of those who started watching football in recent years for fantasy reasons (you know who you are).

This is where John Madden is missed. His folksy personality was extremely hard to dislike. Even his growing detractors couldn’t deny that. Like how Hubie Brown turns you into the player he’s discussing (“Okay, I’m Tim Duncan on the low block …”), Madden could explain the purpose of each play and movement without veering away from the large portion of the audience that had little clue what an A-gap is. He didn’t take himself too seriously, yet, he understood the tremendous responsibility in keeping viewers as informed as they were entertained.

Football is a complicated game. And while this definitely isn’t a call for a comeback by the travel-weary 76-year-old former coach, there’s hope in that maybe one day, the NFL and its TV partners can find someone to carry the mantle.

J. Clinkscales

Jason is the co-host of The Exchange on BlogTalkRadio with Sumit Dasgupta (@skd_thExchange) and the New York Beacon's beat writer for the New York Giants. Also a vastly undersized PF.

More Posts - Website

Follow Me:

Tags: , ,


  • MJ says:

    Watching football isn’t the same without Coach in the booth. There will never be another anchor as entertaining and passionate as John Madden (and I don’t just say that because I’m live in Raider Nation.) On Monday, Coach Madden was in the stadium along with other Raider greats and I was more excited to see him than I was about anything happening on the field.

  • Bruce Leroy says:

    I could not be happier that Madden is gone from the booth. I always felt as though he somehow dropped my IQ just listening to him. He couldn’t show us 3Rivers Stadium without drawing the three rivers.

    One game he was talking about the glare on the field and to show us why there is a glare, he circled the FREAKIN’ SUN! As though there were people in his audience who had never heard of the SUN!!! Moron.

    That and him circling the butt-sweat of the offensive lineman always turned my stomach.

    Goodbye and good riddance.

    • Here’s the thing: I’m with you when it comes to his faults. In a lot of ways, his analyst style didn’t keep up with the speed of football broadcasting over time. However, I do think that there’s plenty of room for someone who can speak to those in the audience that don’t know as much about the game as they think they do; which is honestly most of the audience. Even in local/regional broadcasts, the former players & coaches tend to fall into being too simplisitic or too ‘in the know’.

      I think that’s where Jon Gruden tries to fill in the Madden role, though he relies too much on coach-speak and is too fixated on the offense. And as much as I like Ron Jaworski, he’s better suited for a studio show than he is in the booth.

      And as you might gather, I was never a fan of Cris Collinsworth. For as strong as he is on the technical aspects of calling a game, he can be a bit too sanctimonious and sarcastic.

  • I’m with Jason on this one. Madden, for all his goofiness, was both incredibly insightful, particularly in his earlier announcing days, while still making things simple. And he never seemed to take himself too seriously like some of these guys, and wasn’t a pompous dick either. You could tell how much he really enjoyed football and relaying his information from the game.

Leave a Reply


Leave a Trackback