The Hype Over National Signing Day Is Beyond Disturbing

Football, Trible To Your Bass — By on February 5, 2013 at 7:12 am


Coveted football recruits will sign letters of intent tomorrow to play big-time college football. Many will be met with fanfare, along with plenty of pomp and circumstance. The culmination of likely the biggest decision of a 17 or 18-year old’s life will be a spectacle.

While the athletes have earned the spectacle, the reaction strikes me as disturbing. It’s now the name of the semi-professional college game; a kid can change a program. The recruiting process and coverage of it are a business, and the clientele is hungry for more.

The consumers – large bases of lifelong fans and proud alumni – fuel the process. They want to know where the defensive back is leaning. They’re interested to know if that running back who runs a 4.3 in the 40-yard dash wants to stay close to home.

Information is everywhere. Some recruits take to Twitter and engage with fans. Others – like Mackensie Alexander – try to keep the process private. There’s something special about Alexander’s approach. He’s keeping quiet and safe from the hungry masses. He realizes they are starving for his commitment.

Ask Chris Jones how serious the starvation is. The Houston, MS. defensive end has received death threats over his recent recruiting trips to Ole Miss after his verbal commitment to Mississippi State.

In an interview with ESPN as documented by CBS, Jones recounted the madness:

“It was a crazy weekend,” Jones said. “I received death threats, insane messages, you name it. I mean, it has not been as stressful as people would think it has been. I have tried to handle it in the most comfortable way possible, so it has really been all right for me, and in the end, I am very blessed to have this opportunity to play for either in-state school.”

While there’s certainly a tongue-in-cheek Mississippi joke to be told here, the joke is on no one. A young adult is making a decision and people are willing to threaten his life over it.

There aren’t enough words to describe what’s wrong with this picture. Can we get past the point of being petulant children and let things play out as they will?

It’s an example of the college recruiting game. If Jones goes to school and fails, drops out or transfers, his importance will dwindle to nothing. Another recruit or transfer will take his spot. We’ll all go home happy if the team does well, never mind what happened to Jones. It tells us all we need to know about where big-time college athletes stand in the eyes of many fans.

The kids are athletes. Their personal choices and struggles might be well-documented and reviewed. Yet, at the end of the day, fans want the Chris Jones’ of the world to commit to their school. Then, they want him to stay out of trouble and perform well fairly quickly. Then, they want him to stay in school for the duration of his eligibility.

You see, few of these fans give a damn about Chris Jones. They give a damn about their program. They give a damn about the school where they first learned what it was like to feel a connection to a team. They give a damn about bragging rights over their neighbor who went to a rival school. Jones can provide that. If he doesn’t, what good is he?

It parallels the NFL Draft hype. When a player becomes what he is, it’s really a matter of patterned behavior we see play out. Aside from the end of a career and the very beginning, the quantity is mostly known.

Fans want to see new things. They want to see them grow into great things. Then, they want to see more new things and better things. Eventually, the names on the draft board are the same as the names in the recruiting lists.

They are just numbers and names with measurables. Yet, in the pro game, the rookies are earning paychecks. They’re supposed to be grown men. College recruits are kids. It makes the similar meat market mentality completely sickening. Coaches and staffs are similar. They all eat from the same trough and the eating’s good when the names shoot up the Rivals rankings.

M. Trible

Sports are all I know. Writing came naturally. Sports writer by night & sports writer by night. Philosophy major who thinks the unexamined sport is not worth watching. Always for hire, never for sale. I believe that silence is the virtue of fools and I can't hear you.

More Posts - Website

Follow Me:
TwitterFacebookLinkedInGoogle Plus

Tags: , , , ,


  • GREAT ARTICLE, but this has been happening for YEARS go back to the 30 for 30 Pony Express, I actually think it was worse back then because there was no internet/social media to scrutinize these players/coaches/programs. We saw how dirty the southwest conference was in their pursuit of the best of the best. I think the biggest issue I see now is the access of these guys to joe schmo common fan. They think there is a sense of entitlement to say whatever to these recruits because they are being recruited by their favorite school. This is where I would suggest to any recruit make your social media pages private and allow little to no contact to be able to come from outsiders…

    its really about to get crazy now that the NCAA has essentially removed the “no contact periods” for coaches. I feel bad for SOME of these athletes because they arent prepared for the all this attention. (I say some because there are a handful who encourage it and live to be the center of attention)

  • Da Smoking Ace says:

    Very Good article.

    Two things I can tell you about the big Mississippi schools, fanfare, and boosters.

    Ever since Steve McNair took the spotlight (his Heisman run) from both D-I school in 1993-1994, both Mississippi schools do not want to get outstaged anymore. so they are going after any and everybody that is an athlete in Mississippi. Plus both Mississippi State and Ole Miss can get really nasty when you shun either one ,the other, or both out. C.J. Johnson is a perfect example two years ago.

    …But hey, it is still Mississippi. Calvin Candie would be proud of both schools.

    • Joe Simmons says:


      I was having the same discussion the other day about Mississippi schools with a friend of mine and told him about the whole McNair debacle. Now they over recruit and it’s killing the HBCU’s around the area. It’s good the kids are getting exposure now but the battles of recruiting are really intense.

Leave a Reply


Leave a Trackback